Girl, 4, Died After Dentist Gave Triple Demerol Dose, Warrant Says

An emergency order bars Chrishelle Hemphill from practicing while state regulators pursue allegations involving medication, monitoring and emergency response.

AUSTIN, Texas — Texas dental regulators have temporarily suspended the license and sedation permits of a Fort Worth pediatric dentist accused of failing to meet basic standards of care before a 4-year-old girl died following a sedated dental procedure.

The Texas State Board of Dental Examiners issued the emergency order against Chrishelle Hemphill on Wednesday, July 15, the same day authorities reported her arrest in the death of Aithana Rodriguez Arriaga. The board found that Hemphill’s continued practice would pose what it called a clear, imminent or continuing threat to a person’s physical health or well-being.

The suspension is an administrative action and does not decide the criminal case against Hemphill. She has also been charged with injury to a child causing serious bodily injury, a second-degree felony. Hemphill has not been convicted, and the board’s detailed accusations remain allegations that can be contested through the administrative-hearing process.

The board’s petition alleges that Hemphill oversedated the child and used an inappropriate combination of medications during a tongue-tie procedure at Cuddle Kids Dental Care. Regulators identified chloral hydrate, meperidine, hydroxyzine, nitrous oxide and local anesthetics among the substances administered before the child developed a medical emergency.

Regulators said Hemphill failed to calculate appropriate drug doses and did not account for the combined medications’ ability to suppress the central nervous system and breathing. The petition also alleges that she used a discontinued sedative without fully recognizing its risks and did not adequately consider reports of pediatric deaths associated with chloral hydrate sedation.

The board accused Hemphill of failing to conduct a proper preoperative sedation evaluation or follow required sedation procedures. Its filing also alleges that she did not obtain informed written consent, did not maintain the knowledge and preparation needed to handle a foreseeable emergency and failed to take timely steps necessary to prevent the patient’s death.

Aithana became unresponsive after receiving sedating medications during the April procedure, according to police and court records. Emergency crews took her to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead. The Tarrant County medical examiner attributed her death to meperidine toxicity.

Meperidine is an opioid also known by the brand name Demerol. Investigators said testing found 793 nanograms per milliliter in the child’s blood. A medical examiner told detectives that 200 to 500 nanograms per milliliter was generally considered a therapeutic range for an adult and that the level found in Aithana would have been toxic for an adult.

The regulatory petition also focuses on the response after the girl stopped breathing. It alleges that Hemphill failed to recognize and manage the sedation emergency under accepted protocols and did not administer the appropriate reversal agent. The arrest affidavit says flumazenil was given even though medical experts said naloxone was needed to reverse the opioid’s respiratory effects.

The board separately accused Hemphill of dishonorable conduct, including grossly overprescribing, dispensing or administering narcotic drugs, dangerous drugs or controlled substances. Regulators also alleged violations of state dental laws and professional rules. Those claims will be subject to further administrative proceedings.

Under the suspension, Hemphill may not practice dentistry or delegate clinical work to employees. The order limits her to administrative duties such as opening mail, referring patients and accepting account payments. The board’s website lists her license, No. 33605, among its current temporary suspensions.

The order requires the matter to be scheduled for a hearing before the State Office of Administrative Hearings within 30 days of the suspension. At that proceeding, the dental board must present evidence supporting its request to keep Hemphill’s license and related permits suspended.

Hemphill was licensed to practice dentistry in Texas in 2017 and held permits covering nitrous oxide, multiple levels of sedation and sedation of pediatric patients, according to the board’s filing. Her license will remain suspended while the emergency order is in effect and the administrative case moves forward.

Author note: Last updated July 17, 2026.