Florida Police Chief Accused of On-Duty Sex With Suspect’s Wife

An interim chief is leading the small department as officials release findings against former Chief Michael Giddens and begin recruiting his successor.

HOWEY-IN-THE-HILLS, Fla. — A small Central Florida town is searching for a new police chief after releasing an administrative investigation that found its former chief violated professional conduct rules through a relationship with the estranged wife of a man he had investigated.

Michael Giddens resigned June 3 after being placed on paid administrative leave in May. Newly released findings said he engaged in two consensual sexual encounters while on duty in 2025, when he was a lieutenant, and maintained personal communications with the woman while a fraud investigation involving her husband was underway.

The Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the Lake County Sheriff’s Office examined the allegations. Their findings said Giddens violated town and Police Department policies concerning improper conduct, moral character and sex while on duty. Investigators did not find evidence of a criminal offense.

The report’s release closes one part of the town’s response but leaves officials with a leadership transition in a department that has seven full-time officers and four part-time officers. Interim Chief John Batchelor is overseeing daily operations while the town accepts applications for a permanent chief.

Town officials have set an Aug. 14 deadline for applications. The next chief will serve as the town’s top law enforcement officer and oversee the department’s administration, staffing and public safety work. The department handles patrols, traffic enforcement, emergency calls, crime prevention and community events.

The allegations against Giddens surfaced publicly in early May after an anonymous email was sent to Town Manager Sean O’Keefe and other employees. O’Keefe said at the time that the town took the claims seriously and placed Giddens on leave while officials determined whether they could be supported.

The town asked the Lake County Sheriff’s Office to conduct an administrative investigation as the Florida Department of Law Enforcement pursued its inquiry. The state investigation had begun months earlier, after an agent received a November 2025 report about text messages involving Giddens and the woman.

According to the findings, Giddens opened a potential contractor fraud case against the woman’s husband in December 2024. Giddens contacted the woman in March 2025 while seeking information about the man’s location. Their communication later became personal, and investigators said the two met at hotels in March and May while Giddens was working.

Giddens became police chief in October 2025. He had joined the Howey-in-the-Hills Police Department in 2024 after a long law enforcement career that included service with the Lake County Sheriff’s Office and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

In his resignation letter, Giddens said anonymous individuals were using his private life to distract from the department’s work. He also said he was stepping down to preserve the integrity of the chief’s office and allow officers to remain focused on public safety and community trust.

The investigation reached a different conclusion about whether the conduct was solely private. Its findings tied the relationship to Giddens’ official duties because he met the woman through an active investigation and because the sexual encounters were reported to have occurred while he was on duty.

Giddens’ departure limits the town’s ability to take further personnel action. Officials said they cannot impose employment discipline against a former employee, but they released the investigative findings as part of the public record.

The department remains under Batchelor’s leadership during the search. Town officials say police services will continue throughout the transition, with the next permanent chief expected to take responsibility for rebuilding stable leadership and maintaining public confidence in the agency.

Author note: Last updated July 17, 2026.