A judge said aggravating factors in the 2023 killing of attorney Steven Cozzi outweighed circumstances offered in favor of a life sentence.
CLEARWATER, Fla. — A Florida judge sentenced plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski to death Friday for the 2023 murder of attorney Steven Cozzi, bringing the trial phase of a case built largely on blood evidence, surveillance footage and digital records to a close even though Cozzi’s body has never been found.
Pinellas Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone imposed the sentence after finding Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder in September following a bench trial. Kosowski had waived his right to a jury and represented himself during the murder trial. Bulone previously found two aggravating factors that made Kosowski eligible for the death penalty: that the killing was committed for financial gain and that it was carried out in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner without moral or legal justification.
During the sentencing hearing, Bulone said the aggravating circumstances outweighed mitigating factors considered by the court. Kosowski did not present mitigating evidence on his own behalf, although court-appointed special counsel had raised factors that included his lack of a prior criminal record and his medical career. The judge said the calculated and premeditated nature of the crime carried particular weight in the sentencing decision.
Prosecutors said Kosowski targeted Cozzi because the lawyer represented people Kosowski had sued in a bitter dispute involving a medical practice. Cozzi, 41, disappeared from his Largo law office on March 21, 2023. His wallet, keys and cellphone were left behind, and his body was never recovered.
The state’s case relied on a combination of forensic and circumstantial evidence. Prosecutors said Cozzi’s blood was found in a bathroom at his law office, where investigators believed a violent encounter occurred. Additional evidence connected Kosowski to Cozzi after the disappearance, and surveillance footage showed Kosowski entering the office with a boxed wagon and later leaving with what prosecutors described as a heavily loaded cart.
Investigators also used cellphone information and surveillance video to reconstruct Kosowski’s movements after Cozzi vanished. Prosecutors said he traveled to South Florida and disposed of Cozzi’s body in a commercial trash container. Authorities believe the contents later reached a landfill, where compacted waste made recovery of the remains extremely difficult.
Kosowski disputed the prosecution’s case during his closing argument. He argued that the state had failed to prove how or when Cozzi died and pointed to transactions on Cozzi’s credit card after the date prosecutors said the killing occurred. Kosowski also challenged the state’s theory that he physically moved Cozzi’s body in a wagon and lifted it into his truck. He did not testify or call witnesses during the seven-day trial.
Before sentencing Friday, Kosowski sought to disqualify Bulone from the case. Court records show the judge denied the motion in court and proceeded with sentencing. The Pinellas County court docket recorded a judgment and sentence, the imposition of the death penalty and the appointment of the public defender for the appeal.
Cozzi’s family had previously told the court that the absence of his remains deepened their grief. His husband, Michael Montgomery, said after the guilty verdict that the family had been unable to bring Cozzi home and urged the court to remember him for his life, relationships and work rather than only for the circumstances of his death.
Kosowski is to be transferred to the Florida Department of Corrections. The public defender’s office has been appointed to represent him in appellate proceedings, while Cozzi’s remains have still not been recovered more than three years after his disappearance.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.